The car was on its way to school when ICE agents stopped it in Irving, Texas, on Nov. 4, according to Laura Mejía’s account and earlier reporting. An eight-year-old girl was inside. The adult who cared for her recorded the encounter. In the footage released days later, officers demand that he open the car and one breaks a window. They take the girl away. As of Nov. 18, she was still in a federal shelter in Corpus Christi, even though a Dallas judge had granted sole custody to the couple caring for her.

From a ride to school to a federal shelter

The girl was traveling with one of her caregivers when the stop took place. CBS Texas reported that the officers asked him to open the car, that he refused and that an officer broke a window. The recording documents part of the encounter. What paperwork the officers saw and what basis they relied on to take the girl remain open questions.

The family said that days later the girl was transferred to Corpus Christi and placed with the Office of Refugee Resettlement, or ORR. ICE carried out the stop in Irving. According to the family’s account, ORR became responsible for her care afterward. An ORR spokesperson told CBS Texas that the office does not discuss individual cases.

Allith Galaviz published his recording of the stop on Facebook on Nov. 8. CBS Texas identified him as the person who recorded it. The reel’s caption dates the stop to Nov. 3. Laura Mejía dates it to Nov. 4 in the fundraiser account linked by Galaviz, in line with earlier reporting. An official record is still needed to confirm the exact date.

Watch the caregivers’ CBS Texas interview about the custody ruling.

What ICE and the caregivers say

In a statement to CBS Texas, ICE said that the girl’s biological mother was in immigration custody, had been granted voluntary departure and had chosen to leave with her daughter. ICE says it facilitates their departure together in those circumstances. The agency also said that the caregiver had declined to cooperate with earlier efforts to communicate and assess possible reunification.

The caregiver said he had cooperated. The couple questioned why federal authorities treated the girl as unaccompanied when adults had already been caring for her. ICE defended its officers’ actions and said the appropriate courts and child welfare agencies make decisions about a child’s welfare and custody. These accounts leave a factual question for both sides. What information did the officers have about the girl’s care arrangement when they stopped the car?

The Nov. 17 custody ruling and what followed

On Tuesday, Nov. 17, a Dallas judge granted the caregivers sole custody. In an interview with CBS Texas, one caregiver explained that the decision would allow them to hire an immigration attorney to try to prevent the girl’s removal. He said steps remained before they could pick her up from the shelter.

“We still have to go through a process.” — One of the caregivers, interviewed by Marissa Armas for CBS Texas.

Timeline of the Irving case from Nov. 4 to Nov. 18.
Pulso Demócrata timeline based on CBS Texas, Noticias Telemundo and earlier reporting on the stop.

On Wednesday, Nov. 18, Noticias Telemundo reported that the girl was still at the shelter. That is the latest status documented in the reports reviewed for this story. Confirmation is still needed on the full terms of the order, whether the federal office responsible for the shelter received it and whether a handover date has been set. ORR guidance describes how the agency assesses adults who apply to receive a child. The agency’s next step in this particular case requires a case-specific answer.

The federal rule on releasing children to sponsors puts a parent or legal guardian among the first options and calls for a suitability assessment. That rule supplies the general framework. The child’s case file is needed to determine how it was applied in Irving.

Timeline

  • Nov. 4. Laura Mejía dates the stop in Irving to Nov. 4. Galaviz’s video caption gives Nov. 3.
  • Nov. 8. Galaviz posts his recording of the stop on Facebook.
  • Nov. 13. Noticias Telemundo publishes footage of the car window recorded by a caregiver.
  • Nov. 17. A Dallas judge grants the caregivers sole custody, CBS Texas reports.
  • Nov. 18. Telemundo reports that the girl is still at the federal shelter.

Pulso Demócrata analysis

A custody order should come with a clear explanation to the family about what happens next. In Irving, decisions by two authorities affect the same child. ICE made the initial decision to take her from the car. A state judge later determined who would have custody. While she remained at a shelter, the responsible federal office could tell her caregivers which step is still pending, who can complete it and how the family will hear about it.

ICE should also explain what it checked before separating a child from the people taking her to school. The agency and the caregiver disagree about prior cooperation. That makes the sequence of documents, notices and decisions especially important. The adults and agencies can defend their accounts. The girl needs a clear answer about what happens next.

Credits and sources

CBS Texas interviewed the caregiver and obtained the statements from ICE and ORR. Allith Galaviz recorded and posted the video of the stop. Noticias Telemundo aired an excerpt on Nov. 13 and reported the Nov. 18 follow-up. The source list links to the family’s post, news reports and background documents.